Sunday, September 17, 2017

Spoiler Sunday--Why All Of The [REDACTED] Hatred, DC?!?

You've almost certainly heard by now, or at least heard the theories, about the identity of the mysterious "Mr. Oz," who has been manipulating events in the nu52/Rebirth DC Universe.

Well, surprise, surprise: I have some things to say about that revelation.

So, if you don't want to be spoiled, well, come back later.

SPOILERS begin of the 5 pictures of Oz...





Still there?

Well, there is no sense beating around the bush, is there? This week's Action Comics #987 reveals that Mr. Oz is:

OK, then.

Now, I'll grant any caveats you like: this is just the beginning of a 4-part story; it could easily turn out not to really be Jor-El; it could be a dude from an alternate universe or such; he could be a Dr. Manhattan experiment gone awry; yada yada.

Still, this seems likely to be one more example of DC's growing hatred of Krypton.

Look, I know there have always been Kryptonian bad guys. That's what the Phantom Zone is for. Every society has it's bad apples.

And Krypton was certainly not perfect--the stupid science council ignored Jor-El's warnings, for one thing.

But still, Krypton was always presented as, if not necessarily a utopia, at least a decent place. They were pretty much like us, just more advanced. Humans could travel to Krypton (via time travel) or to Kandor, and fit right in, and be accepted. It was a good place, that had a tragic ending.

But let's look at what DC has told us in the last few years:

**The first Rebirth arc of Justice League had the Kryptonian god Rao--yup, the actual Rao--as a villain. It's turns out Rao was a parasite, a demon who tried to turn everyone on Earth into a Kryptonian so he could absorb their energy.

**The Cyborg Superman--OK, look, there are two separate Cyborg Supermen running around the Rebirth universe right now, because DC is bereft of ideas. Anyway, the Cyborg Superman I'm talking about, who wants to destroy Earth (and pretty much anything not Kryptonian) is Zor-El, Supergirl's father (and Kal-El's uncle).

**The villains of DKIII? The Master Race? Kandorians. When their enlarged, they turn out to be evil dickweeds who want to take over Earth, or, failing that, blow it up.

**Prior to the nu52, of course, Kandor was also enlarged, and, surprise, they were dickweeds. Not evil per se, but arrogant pricks who pretty much hate humans and allow themselves to goaded into the "War Of The Supermen."

**H'el, a Kryptonian (of some sort), who was going to destroy the Earth in order to make a time warp that would allow him to keep Krypton from exploding in the first place.

**The Eradicator is back, and is a nationalist/racist asshole, wanting to destroy everything non-Kryptonian and recreate Krypton on Earth.

**The asteroid that made Vandal Savage immortal? It was from Krypton.

There are more examples, but I'm too lazy to look them up right now.

And so things have reached the point where it's plausible that Jor-El--JOR-EL!!--is a genocidal madman, essentially Eradicator 2.0, willing to bend time and space and destroy millions because...well, because humans suck:



We've seen him straight-up murder people, and imprison others who might interfere with his plans. And here's the half of the issues lenticular cover that represents him:

The House Of El symbol made up of corpses. How. Nice.

This is the state of Krypton in today's DC Universe--that, without too much cognitive dissonance, we can believe that Superman's dad is Darkseid Jr.

We are apparently supposed to seriously believe that Kal-El and Kara are the only good people from Krypton. That everyone else--including their parents!!--was xenophobic, genocidal maniacs who held any other life-form in contempt. That Krypton was a hellhole filled with assholes who would as soon wipe us out as look at us.

The question, of course, is why in the world DC has chosen this direction. Why make Krypton nothing but a source of evil, constantly bedeviling Earth? Why make half of Superman's heritage Kryptonian supremacists whose only function is to torment Kal-El and company? Why moot the tragedy of Krypton's destruction by positing that, well, they kind of deserved it?

What dramatic purpose is served by treating krypton this way? Is it just another manifestation of the misguided "heroes must suffer" mantra--just Superman's version of Flash's mother having to die for him to be a hero? Are the current creators so insecure that Kal-El would choose to defend Earth that they have to make his other home look indefensible in contrast?!?

I just don't get it.

10 comments:

Siskoid said...

They think shock is all that drives comics sales.

Sina said...

& again, my belief is that Supes is totally human..."just because they're Kryptonian, doesn't mean they're not human" 😊 if they wanted to, they could even pull in Karen Starr/Power-Girl's now-defunct origin as being from Atlantis & reveal that ancient humanity left Earth before the cataclysm to go to Krypton, then came back, etc. thus tying in Aquaman, Superman, Supergirl & more as good, extended continuity 😎

Sina said...

I hate all this xenophobic "alien" shit that they've put on Superman

JohnJ said...

So what do you think this means for the "Krypton" tv series on Syfy this fall? I had no idea what they had in mind and hearing that Adam Strange, Hawkwoman and other DC characters will be involved has just added to my confusion.

But these are the same folk who seem to be readying us for a teenage Batman on "Gotham" soon.

DanielT said...

The joke used to be "Jor-El and Lara were the only ones to actually die on Krypton." Now...

My favorite thing about the Byrne revamp was Superman being the ONLY survivor of Krypton. I could live with Krypto (using him to test a spaceship prototype is plausible) and Supergirl for historical reasons. But Kandorians, Phantom Zone prisoners, The Eradicator, etc., I say be done with them all.

Madman said...

You said it earlier, Snell. DC is totally bereft of ideas. Sad

B Smith said...

It's enough to make one think kindly of Mort Weisinger

-3- said...

I generally hate to say things like this, but i've come to the conclusion that the people making decisions at the Big Two are simply not decent human beings.
You have to have somthing of a good person in yourself to see the good in others. They can't.
Do the math.

SallyP said...

I have pretty much given up on DC lately, but was considering giving the new new new re birth a chance.

Well, so much for THAT idea!

googum said...

Man, when Dev-Em, the Knave from Krypton, finally shows up; how evil is that guy gonna be?